Binomial analysis by the Goldvarb
programme indicates that in the debates the probability of occurrence of the traditional
[e ] variant is very high (0.83) while in the news broadcasts this probability drops to a
correspondingly low level (0.23) (Logarithm of similarity: -163041, sig=0.000, X2 test
= 0.0000).
Looking at
gender of interviewees, we observe that both in the debates and in the news broadcasts,
women are surprisingly more likely than the men to maintain the traditional [e ] variant.
Table
2. (Logarithm of similarity: -175579, sig=0.000).
PROBABILITY THAT THE [e] VARIANT WILL BE
MAINTAINED |
NEWSCASTS |
DEBATES |
Women |
Men |
Women |
Men |
0.32 |
0.00 |
0.94 |
0.80 |
5. General observations
Comparison of
results shows similar or parallel linguistic behaviour in both the inhabitants of the
village of Alguaire and the speakers on Lleida television. Indeed, we observe that, in
general, in predominantly formal speech events, there is a tendency to use phonological
forms that coincide with the written standard and, as a consequence, to begin to lose the
morphology which has traditionally characterised the Lleidatà dialect.
Analysis of the
most formal speech events shows that realisations of the verb morphemes can be classified
in three well differentiated groups clustering by event: a) those occurring in the
television newscasts, where the probability of maintaining [e] is a low 0.23; b)
the realisations recorded during the questionnaire and responses to the same carried out
with villagers of Alguaire, where the probability of maintaining [e] is a high 0.819; c)
the phonological realisations culled from the debates on regional television, where the
probability of maintaining [e] is again high, 0.83.
This in turn
enables us to explain variable loss of the traditional form [e] in favour of [] as a result of, in the first place, the influence of
the written language on the spoken language and this is especially clear, given
that the lowest incidence of the traditional variant is found in written discourse
intended for oral delivery (news bulletins); and in the second place, the fact that in
general, in the Lleida dialect, the unstressed vowels written <a> are pronounced []. Among speakers in the Alguaire sample, it can be
seen that length of schooling in Catalan is a crucial factor in explaining the loss of
dialect features, once again corroborating the connection between the oral and written
language.
In less formal
speech there is absolute maintenance of the traditional [e] in the spontaneous
conversation of the Alguaire interviewees, other than just sporadic occurrence of [] among speakers aged 6 to 11. Alongside this, we find
quite marked alternation with the imperfect indicative endings, between [a e] and [ae], which become reduced
to [ae] and [a] ein the most formal speech events. In the conversations and the
interview, the most frequent realisation of [ae] is
once again found among speakers of school age, when adapting their pronunciation to the
norms of the written language.
6.
Bibliography
ANIANSSON, E.
"Barns sprakliga förmaga: Redogörelse för ett par test." FUMS Rapport.
[Uppsala] (1981), no. 84.
BAYLEY, R.
"The Quantitative Paradigm." J. K. Chamberts; P. Trudgill; N. Schilling-Estes
(eds.) The Handbook of Language Variation and Change. Massachusetts: Blackwell
(2002), p. 117-141.
BELL, A.
"Language style as audience design." Language in Society. (1984), no. 13,
p. 145-204.
BIBER, D. "An
Analytical Framework for Register Studies." D. Biber; E. Finegan (eds.) Sociolinguistic
Perspectives on Register. New York and Oxford: Oxford University Press (1994), p.
31-56.
BRIGGS, C. Learning
How to Ask: A Sociolinguistic Apprasial of the Role of the Interview in Social Science
Research. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1986.
BROWN, P.;
LEVINSON, S. "Social structure, groups, and interaction." K. R. Scherer, H.
Giles (eds.) Social markers in speech. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press
(1979), p. 291-341.
CARRERA-SABATÉ,
J. "L'estadística en l'anàlisi de la variació fonètica: una
aplicació del programa Goldvarb." Noves SL, primavera
de 2002a http://www.gencat.cat/llengua/noves
CARRERA-SABATÉ,
J. Escola catalana i variació fonètica. Una evolució del vocalisme àton a Alguaire
i a Lleida. Lleida: Pagès Editors, 2002b.
CASANOVAS M.;
CREUS, I. "Apunts sobre el lleidatà: fonètica i morfosintaxi." Zeitschrift
für Katalanistik, (1999), no. 12, p. 83-108.
CHAMBERS, J. K.;
TRUDGILL, P. SCHILLING-ESTES, N. The Handbook of Language Variation and Change.
Massachusetts: 2002.
CREUS, I. La
flexió verbal a Bell-lloc dUrgell. Un estudi morfofonològic. Dissertation.
Lleida: Universitat de Lleida, 1997.
CREUS, I. "La
morfologia verbal nord-occidental." Estudis de Llengua i Literatura Catalanes
XLV. Barcelona: PAM, (2002), no. 1, p. 33-66.
DE CESARIS, J. A.
"Les divisions dialectals del català". Actes del Setè Col·loqui
Internacional de Llengua i Literatura Catalanes. Barcelona: PAM, (1986), p. 679-701.
ECKERT, P. Linguistic
variation as social practice. Oxford: Massachusetts: 2000.
GILI I GAYA, S. Estudi
fonètic del parlar de Lleida. Miscel·lània Filològica dedicada a D. Antoni M.
Alcover. Palma de Mallorca: Círculo de Estudios, 1931.
GRIERA, A.
"El català nord-occidental." Butlletí de Dialectologia Catalana,
[Barcelona] (1920), núm. VIII.
GREGORY, M.;
CARROLL, S. Lenguaje y situación. Variedades del lenguaje y sus contextos sociales.
México: Fondo de Cultura Económica. [Trans. of: Language and Situation. Language
Varieties and their Social Contexts.], [1978] 1986.
HALLIDAY, M. A. K.
El lenguaje como semiótica social. La interpretación social del lenguaje y del
significado. México: Fondo de Cultura Económica. [Trad. de Language as Social
Semiotics. The Social Interpretation of Language and Meaning. Arnold. London.], [1976]
1982.
HAZEN, K. Identity
and Ethnicity in the Rural South: A Sociolinguistic View through Past and Present be.
Durham: Duke University Press, 2000.
HYMES, D. Foundations
in sociolinguistics: An ethnographic approach. Philadelphia: University of
Pennsylvania Press, 1974.
INSTITUT D'ESTUDIS
CATALANS. Proposta per a un estàndard oral de la llengua catalana. II. Morfologia.
Barcelona: IEC, [1992] 1994.
LABOV, W. The
social stratification of English in New York City. Washington D.C.: Center for Applied
Linguistics, (1966), p. 170-171.
LABOV, W. Sociolinguistic
patterns. Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press, 1972.
LLORET, M. R.;
VIAPLANA, J. "Variació, fonologia i morfologia." M. R. Lloret et al.
(eds.) Anàlisi de la variació lingüística. PPU. Barcelona: PPU, (1997), p.
93-120.
MARTÍ, J. Contribució
a l'estudi del dialecte occidental. Tarragona: Diputació Provincial de Tarragona,
1970.
PORTZ, R.
"Another look at stages in the acquisition of standard English." Ninth
International Congress of Phonetic Sciences. Copenhagen, 1979.
PUEYO, M. L'estructura
fonològica del vocalisme lleidatà. Manuscript. Lleida, 1976.
RAND, D.; SANKOFF,
D. GoldVarb: A Variable Rule Application for the Macintosh (version 2.1).
Montréal: Centre de recherches mathématiques de la Universitat de Montréal, 1991.
RECASENS, D. Fonètica
descriptiva del català. Barcelona: IEC, [1991] 1996.
ROBINSON, J.;
LAWRENCE, H.; TAGLIAMONTE, S. A Multivariate Analysis Application for Windows. Users
manual. York: Universitat de York, 2001.
ROMERO, S.
"Escolarització i variació intralingüística: el cas de larticle etimològic
en el català nord-occidental." Jornades sobre Llengua i Ensenyament, (1995),
no, I, p. 225-236.
SANKOFF, D.
"A quantitative paradigm for the study of communicative competence." Bauman, R.;
Sherzer, J. (eds.) Explorations in the Ethnography of Speaking. Cambridge:
Cambridge University Press, (1974), p. 18-50.
SEGARRA, M. Història
de lortografia catalana. Barcelona: Empúries, 1985.
SISTAC, R.
"El dialecte nord-occidental en els àmbits d'actuació formals." Jornades de
la Secció Filològica de l'IEC a Lleida. Barcelona: IEC, (1992), p. 39-43.
SOLANS, E.
"Introducció a la morfosintaxi de la parla nord-occidental (Lleida)". Ilerda
Humanitats [Lleida] (1990), no. XLVIII, p. 209-215.
SPILLNER, B.
"Style and register." U. Ammon, N. Dittmar i J.Mattheier (eds.) Sociolinguistics.
Berlin: Mouton de Gruyter (1987), no. I, p. 273-285.
TURULL, A.
"Notes sobre el lleidatà". Ilerda Humanitats. [Lleida] (1990), no.
XLVIII, p. 201-206.
VENY, J. Els
parlars catalans. Palma de Mallorca: Raixa, 19823.
VIAPLANA, J. Dialectologia.
València: Universitat de València, 1996.
YOUNG, R.; BAYLEY,
R. "VARBRUL analysis for second language acquisition research." Bayley, R.;
Preston, D. R. (eds.) Second Language Acquisition and Linguistic Variation.
Amsterdam: John Benjamins (1996), p. 253-306.
Josefina
Carrera-Sabaté
University of Barcelona and University of Lleida
josefinacarrera@teleline.es |