Table 2. Continuities and
discontinuities of the process of linguistic replacement
Source: Own elaboration.
The
discontinuous lines show us the changes that can be produced (the discontinuities
naturally) meanwhile the continuous line indicates us the evolution without any kind of
changes.
The parallelism that we can
establish between the catastrophe theory and the process of linguistic replacement is so
big, that we get to describe these processes with the characteristics of a type of
discontinuities (the "butterfly catastrophe") and we dont have to add or
remove anything; this is why we can affirm that the relation established is of isomorphism
(6). This fact allows us to
decide which have to be the facts that take part of the processes because they will be the
same as in the "butterfly catastrophe".
Before starting
to comment this isomorphism we have to define the concepts that are going to be candidates
to the same control facts (the same forces) that take part in the catastrophe theory,
leaving at one side the concept of social representation that we have already shaped
before.
We will start with the reference
group, Merton and Kitt (1950) that characterise it as follows:
"It points out to systemise the determinants and the consequences from the
evolution processes and self evaluation, in which the individuals have to assume
the values and rules of other individuals and groups as a reference frame".
Secondly, we
will say that the social net is the group of people that share one of their
languages and have linguistic interactions between them.
Let us see the column on the
left in the following table, which represent the facts that take part in the
"butterfly catastrophe".
Table 3. Proposal
of isomorphism of the controlling facts from the "butterfly catastrophe" and
from the process of linguistic substitution
CONTROLLING FACTS FROM THE
"BUTTERFLY CATASTROPHE": |
CONTROLLING FACTS OF THE PROCESS OF
LINGUISTIC SUBSTITUTION
OR
VARIABLES THAT
INFLUENCE ABOVE THE GRADES OF LANGUAGE USE. |
ATTRACTIONS:
-NORMAL FACTS
-SEPARATION FACTS |
REPRESENTATION OF THE REFERENCE GROUP
+OF LANGUAGE A
+OF LANGUAGE B |
WARP FACTS |
+REPRESENTATION OF LANGUAGE B |
"BUTTERFLY FACTS" (= AS A
COMPROMISE) |
REPRESENTATION + FROM THE SOCIAL NET OF
L2 |
Source: Own
elaboration. |